Robert Wagner, left, and John Bunting...just a coupla fellas who liked a bit of fun ("fun" for them being multiple murders and torture)
JOHN BUNTING was a closet homosexual, so ashamed of his long-suppressed desires that he became a gay-basher/gay-murderer. It's not stated anywhere as a fact, but that's the natural conclusion I came to after reading two books about his masterminding of the bloody and brutal Snowtown serial killings - the so-called "Bodies In The Barrels" case - that rocked South Australia during the 1990s.
What other reason explains why Bunting spent so much of his adult life socialising with "dirtys" (as he liked to call them) - gays, bisexuals, transsexuals, paedophiles (who happened to be gay) and transvestites?
Sure, he inhabited a pretty perverse, incestuous social circle but come on!...it's not like the freaks he hung out with were an everyday occurrence in South Oz. How does one go about befriending so many perverts in economically depressed areas like Salisbury (in Adelaide's bleak northern suburbs) and rural Murray Bridge?
Well, Bunting did. Along with his chief partners-in-crime Robert Wagner, James Vlassakis and Mark Haydon (nee Mark Lawrence), the group tortured and murdered 11 (and probably 12) people from 1992 to their arrest in 1999. Hanging, strangulation, crushing skulls with blunt objects - the killing methods varied but the torture methods stayed unnervingly the same (all I'll say on this is that I'll never look at sparklers the same way again).
While the majority of murders took place in metropolitan Adelaide and nearby satellite town Murray Bridge, the final murder of David Johnson occurred in the small northern town of Snowtown. This is also where the killers eventually stored 10 of the 12 bodies, in barrels of acid kept in the vault of a disused bank they had rented. Hence, and somewhat unfairly, they were dubbed the "Snowtown murders".
At first the group justified their crimes as ridding the streets of paedophiles and homosexuals (who were one and the same thing according to ringleader Bunting, who claimed he had also been molested as a child). But as time went on and the frequency of murders increased, it became clear the motives really hinged on pure pleasure in inflicting pain and, strangely enough, monetary gain. Nearly all the victims' government pensions and/or dole money were kept going courtesy of numerous deceptions and frauds perpetrated by the killers and their families/loved ones).
Nearly everyone involved was a friend of a friend or a relative or a loved one or involved in one of the killings.
THE KILLERS were all close friends. Hell, Bunting was even considered a virtual step-dad to Vlassakis. But things get even more interesting when you look at the complicated web weaved between the killers and THEIR VICTIMS:
* CLINTON TREZISE: gay lover of Barry Lane, who was called upon to help dispose of Trezise's body
* RAY DAVIES: known paedophile who was friends with Barry Lane and Suzanne Allen's ex-lover. Bunting's defacto Elizabeth Harvey (Vlassakis' mother) most likely helped in Davies' murder
* SUZANNE ALLEN: former lover of Ray Davies and John Bunting. Supposedly she knew too much about the first two killings
* BARRY LANE: gay lover of Clinton Trezise, Thomas Trevilyan and Robert Wagner. Friend of Ray Davies. Lane, a convicted paedophile, helped dispose of Trezise's body. He reached the end of his usefulness after providing Bunting information about alleged paedophiles in Adelaide. And Lane knew too much. This was also considered a revenge killing for the sexual abuse Lane had done to Wagner when the pair were in a relationship
* MICHAEL GARDINER: Gay housemate of Nicole Zurrita, who was a cousin of Robert Wagner's girlfriend Vicki Mills. Bunting and Wagner equated homosexuals with paedophiles and hated both with a passion
* THOMAS TREVILYAN: gay lover of Barry Lane, who was involved with his murder. Mentally unstable, he was considered a liability. He was hung from a tree outside Adelaide and it was made to look like a suicide
* GAVIN PORTER: Vlassakis' best friend. A heavy drug user and Bunting despised druggies.
* TROY YOUDE: Elizabeth Harvey's son and Vlassakis' half-brother. Youde molested Vlassakis repeatedly when they were young teenagers. That sealed his fate when Vlassakis told Bunting about the abuse. This was the first hands-on killing involving Vlassakis and, possibly, Haydon
* FRED BROOKS: Son of Jodie Elliott, who was engaged to John Bunting (while Bunting was still in a relationship with Elizabeth Harvey). Bunting hated him
* GARY O'DWYER: Bunting's brain-damaged neighbour in Murray Bridge whose only crime was that Bunting thought he looked a lot like Troy Youde
* ELIZABETH HAYDON: Mark Haydon's wife and sister to Jodie Elliott. She knew too much and was silenced
* DAVID JOHNSON: Vlassakis' step-brother. Bunting thought he was a snob who looked down on him. That was enough. Vlassakis later alleged in court Bunting and Wagner also fried and ate a piece of Johnson's flesh after his murder.
What you have here is one of the most bizarre and unique serial murder cases in the world. A group of like-minded individuals preying on their own kind.
And in this dysfunctional world, 12 missing people were hardly noticed (and, if so, were rarely reported missing by friends and family to the police, who were feared and distrusted by this particular sub-culture of the community).
This allowed Bunting, Wagner and co. to get away with their abhorrent behaviour for seven years.
Eventually, the four men were arrested and charged with homicide. Vlassakis pleaded guilty to four murders and turned State's evidence on Bunting and Wagner, who were both convicted in 2004 of multiple murders after one of the longest cases in South Australian history. Haydon received a lesser jail sentence for assisting them but avoided the murder charges.
As you can see, Snowtown was a fucking complicated, highly confusing case. I haven't even come close to summarising it properly for you in just a few short paragraphs. So how did the professionals go?
I read Jeremy Pudney's Snowtown (HarperCollins) first, mainly 'cos he used to co-read the TV news with Helen in the Riverland many years ago. He went on to work as a journalist with The Adelaide Advertiser and Network 10 and covered this case extensively for those news outlets. This is Pudney's first book - the blurb on the back states it'll "take its place among the classics of the true crime genre". Bollocks.
Pudney has written a succinct 90-page book on the murders. Sadly, his publishers wanted 270 pages, so he repeats it THREE times. Firstly, he tells us how all the victims went missing from the killers' perspective, then he tells us how they were murdered, then he quotes verbatim from the prosecutor at the trial on what happened. This is just fuckin' lazy. And, even after that, the book is still kinda boring. Also, certain facts on the case have been omitted - for legal reasons - to allow the book to be sold in South Australia. That means the cannibalism snippet is excised along with certain other facts. All in all, it's a shoddy piece of work
The Snowtown Murders (ABC Books) by Andrew McGarry starts out more promisingly. A journo with The Australian, McGarry's not afraid to tell all the facts (which is why the book can't be sold in South Australia). He also links this case with the other notorious cases in SA's recent past which has helped cement Adelaide (somewhat unjustly) as Australia's "weirdo murder capital". But within a few pages the errors start racking up: typos, wrong years listed, wrong names listed, sentences missing, even whole paragraphs, factual errors (eg. South Australian town Port Pirie is two hours north of Adelaide, not "west of Adelaide"). I mean, where was the bloody proofreader on this book? It destroys McGarry's credibility. In the end, I couldn't overcome the stacks of mistakes to fully enjoy the book. Pity, as it still blew away Pudney's steaming turd of an effort.
So what have I learned from the "Bodies In The Barrels" case? Well, I doubt I'll ever stop my car in the northern suburbs of Adelaide again. Too many paedophiles there for my taste.
Also, I've discovered that just reporting on a juicy multiple murder case doesn't qualify a person to knock out a book if they can't write for shit.
Finally, there's one positive for John Bunting these days: he's enjoying lots of hot gay sex in jail. So at least he's happy.

The bank in Snowtown that housed some unspeakably evil secrets